FarmLand Assessment Tool
Background
In support of the Intervale Center’s mission to strengthen community food systems that sustain farms, land, and people, and in response to opportunities to expand our land-base, replicate our model, and mitigate risks associated with climate change, we have developed the following assessment tools to help us evaluate parcels for acquisition.
The Intervale Center currently manages 360 acres in the Intervale, where farmers and gardeners produce food and trees, community members recreate, and significant acreage is managed for wildlife habitat, ecological health, and community food production. After flooding in 2023 and 2024, we completed a flood resilience survey with Intervale farmers, determining that in addition to investing in flood resilience in the Intervale, farmers desire access to other land as a risk management strategy. At the same time, the Intervale Center views potential land expansion as a way to further our organization’s mission and goals, demonstrating our unique land use and management model in a different community and bio-region. New lands could help us:
Grow more farmers and local foods
Increase community access to locally produced food
Demonstrate community food production and resource protection
Provide recreational, wildlife, biodiversity and other services
Build food system resilience in the face of climate breakdown
Demonstrate our statewide reach and leadership
Generate new income for the Intervale Center
Building on the strength of tools created in the past by the Intervale Center, California Farmlink, and others, it is our hope that this set of tools will help us take a more proactive approach to land search, allowing us to compare parcels to further hone the kind of parcel we seek and understand what parcels and projects we are uniquely suited to manage. We also hope this tool can be used by farmers, service providers, and organizations to help them quickly understand what land will best suit their needs and evaluate and compare land acquisition opportunities. It is designed to help you have productive conversations about what parcel is right for you.
Our ranking system
Our tool is divided into nine categories with features that can be scored based on positive, neutral or negative attributes. These scores will be subjective based on your intended end use. Once a parcel is assessed, one can view the Summary Table to quickly view where the parcel is strong and where it may be lacking. We have also included a “hard pass” ranking that should be separately considered in addition to the score. Our intention is to create an evaluation process that helps us and others understand our top priority needs and dealbreakers and can guide productive decision-making conversations. One can use these tools on their own or combine them with the financial workbook we have also created.
Directions
Before you use this tool to evaluate a parcel, be sure you have a clear understanding of the programs, enterprises, and other uses you would like to establish and what you will need to achieve your vision. This is important because it will impact how you rank different categories. For instance, if your dream is to house a livestock operation with public access trails, your needs will be different than if you are hoping to support vegetable production and value-added processing. If your vision is more flexible, that’s ok, too; just be sure to know what your dealbreakers are. You can document your wants and needs by completing the “Understanding Priorities” worksheet. Rank top priorities and include associated parameters on this sheet, and then write a short summary describing the type of parcel that will best suit your needs. Then you will be ready to evaluate parcels using the land assessment worksheet.
To help you complete your assessment, we have created a guide that provides directions on questions to ask and resources to gather that will help you with your evaluation. Your next step is to gather this data. Then analyze it based on your needs to determine whether the parcel has a positive, neutral or negative ranking on each feature, using the provided questions as a jumping off point. Put an x in the corresponding ranking box. The sheet will automatically calculate totals and create a summary table for quick analysis and for comparison of multiple parcels. Only you know what your priorities are and what will make or break your project. Scores are subjective and should be considered an indicator of the property’s strengths and weaknesses. Keep in mind if a category was half neutral and half positive, it will score 60%. Any category scoring 60% or more is considered high scoring; anything scoring under 40% is considered low scoring.
Finally, we have created a financial workbook that you can complete alongside the assessment tool. This workbook is designed to give you a quick look at how your plan for the property may operate financially. The workbook provides a basic framework for decision making. If the initial financial assessment is positive, then the next steps laid out in the workbook instructions should be followed, with assistance from a service provider if necessary. It is not intended to replace business planning. Instructions for the workbook are contained in an instructions tab.